## Code Review ### Spec Pattern Search (REQUIRED) - Searched for existing spec patterns: `find spec -name "*spec.rb" | sort` - Found existing spec files: - spec/models/proposal_spec.rb ✓ - spec/requests/api/v1/mcp_spec.rb ✓ - spec/factories/proposals.rb ✓ - spec/features/proposals_spec.rb ✓ - spec/requests/proposals_spec.rb ✓ - Similar patterns found: All relevant spec files exist and were mostly updated ### Test Results - Test suite run: `bundle exec rspec` - Results: 714 examples, **3 failures**, 7 pending ### Test Failure Analysis **Pre-existing failures (2)** - Unrelated to this PR: 1. spec/features/dashboard_spec.rb:4 - Dashboard content issue 2. spec/features/dashboard_spec.rb:17 - Kanban link issue **NEW failure caused by this PR (1)**: 3. spec/features/proposals_spec.rb:20 - `ActiveRecord::RecordInvalid: Validation failed: Confidence is not a number` **Root Cause**: `spec/features/proposals_spec.rb:21` still uses `confidence: "high"` (string) but the migration changed confidence to integer (0-100). The PR updated: - ✓ spec/factories/proposals.rb (default changed to 50) - ✓ spec/models/proposal_spec.rb (validation test updated) - ✓ spec/requests/api/v1/mcp_spec.rb (uses numeric values like 75) But **missed updating**: - ✗ spec/features/proposals_spec.rb (still uses confidence: "high" string) ### Spec Coverage Check - Files changed: - db/migrate/20251231171527_*.rb - Migration file - app/models/proposal.rb - Model validation change - app/models/ticket.rb - Added worker_confidence, reviewer_confidence - app/avo/resources/proposal.rb - Avo admin UI - app/controllers/api/v1/mcp_controller.rb - API schema - app/controllers/proposals_controller.rb - Filter logic - app/helpers/proposals_helper.rb - Badge helper - app/views/proposals/index.html.haml - UI filter - app/serializers/ticket_serializer.rb - Added confidence fields - spec/factories/proposals.rb - Updated ✓ - spec/models/proposal_spec.rb - Updated ✓ - spec/requests/api/v1/mcp_spec.rb - Updated ✓ - Required specs found: Most present - **Missing spec update**: spec/features/proposals_spec.rb line 21 needs `confidence: 75` instead of `confidence: "high"` ### Findings - **Database migration**: Good approach with proper data mapping (low→25, medium→50, high→75) ✓ - **Model validations**: Correctly changed from enum to numericality ✓ - **API schema**: Updated to use integer type with min/max ✓ - **UI updates**: Numeric input and color-coded badges ✓ - **Worker/Reviewer confidence**: Added to tickets model ✓ - **Code quality**: Clean implementation - **Security**: No issues detected - **Implementation**: Matches ticket requirements - **Breaking changes**: Migration handles data conversion properly ### Decision **FAIL - Test Suite Not Passing** The PR has good implementation but a single test file wasn't updated: `spec/features/proposals_spec.rb:21` uses `confidence: "high"` which must be changed to `confidence: 75`. Once this one-line fix is applied, all tests should pass (the other 2 failures are pre-existing).