## Code Review ### Spec Pattern Search (REQUIRED) - Searched for existing spec patterns: `find spec -name "*spec.rb" | sort` - Found existing spec files: - spec/features/approvals_spec.rb, dashboard_spec.rb, debug_dashboard_spec.rb, kanban_board_spec.rb, etc. - spec/requests/api/v1/*, spec/requests/*_spec.rb - spec/models/*_spec.rb - Similar patterns found: Feature specs exist for UI components ### Test Results - Test suite run: `bundle exec rspec` - Results: 714 examples, **2 failures**, 7 pending **Failures (caused by this PR):** 1. `spec/features/dashboard_spec.rb:4` - Dashboard User views the dashboard 2. `spec/features/dashboard_spec.rb:17` - Dashboard User navigates to Kanban board These failures occur because the PR added `before_action :require_login` to `ApplicationController`, protecting all routes. The existing `dashboard_spec.rb` tests now get redirected to login instead of accessing protected pages. ### Spec Coverage Check - Files changed: - app/controllers/application_controller.rb (modified - added authentication) - app/controllers/sessions_controller.rb (new) - app/views/layouts/application.html.haml (modified - navigation changes) - app/views/sessions/new.html.haml (new) - config/routes.rb (modified) - New specs added: - spec/features/sessions_spec.rb (209 lines) - comprehensive feature tests for login/logout - spec/requests/sessions_spec.rb (122 lines) - request-level tests - Missing specs: - spec/features/dashboard_spec.rb - **NEEDS UPDATE** (existing test broken by authentication) - No controller spec for ApplicationController changes ### Findings - **Code quality:** Clean, well-structured Rails authentication using session - **Security:** Good - includes session fixation protection (reset_session), rate limiting (5 attempts/hour), password-type input - **Implementation:** Matches ticket requirements - no Devise, uses existing Agent.api_key - **Breaking changes:** YES - existing feature specs (dashboard_spec.rb) broken by authentication requirement ### Decision **FAIL - Tests Failing** The PR breaks existing tests. The `before_action :require_login` added to `ApplicationController` causes `dashboard_spec.rb` tests to fail because they don't authenticate first. **Action Required:** 1. Update `spec/features/dashboard_spec.rb` to log in before accessing protected pages, OR 2. Add `skip_before_action :require_login` in test mode via a test helper Example fix pattern: ```ruby # In spec/features/dashboard_spec.rb - add before block: before { visit login_path; fill_in "api_key", with: agent.api_key; click_button "Log In" } ``` The new `sessions_spec.rb` tests are comprehensive and well-written. Once the existing broken tests are fixed, this PR should be ready for approval.